RC, what's the best home automation alexa replacement?

Started by Drastic, November 18, 2026, 04:42:44 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Drastic

We have an alexa in every room, mainly using it to control lights and fans. I cannot believe how dumb the thing still is during the ai boom. I also get extremely pissed when the Internet is out (fiber modem died a couple weeks ago) and it won't work, which is still ridiculous.

What's a good replacement without being tied to someone's connected, listening devices? Something that just runs on the local network and nothing updates unless I update it.

rcjordan

I use Hubitat which is zigbee and zwave (and now probably has more types of connectivity). BUT I use Alexa dot2s to interface with Hubitat for voice control (Echo, turn off all downstairs lights).

What I'm seeing the most of lately is Home Assistant.  I don't know much about it, but if I'd start by checking out HA if I didn't already have Hubitat.

ESP32-based systems are coming on strong --but I don't know how mature they are.

In the end, it's the availability & cost of non-proprietary, actionable devices (wall switches, receptacles, motion detectors) that make your system. A gee-whiz hub doesn't do you much good if no one makes the device you need or it's $100.

rcjordan

+
Hubitat (I run a C7 model, current is C8 & C8 Pro) is rock-rock-rock solid.  Absolutely local once set up. Truly does not care if the internet fails. Good online community. Inexpensive.

ergophobe

Have you looked into Aqara? That's my brother's weapon of choice

rcjordan

> Aqara

No, my issue with hubitat is that it is so stable that my purposely K.I.S.S. setup runs for many months without maintenance, repair, or code changes. This means I get ice-cold on admin stuff and only have casual contact with smarthome news. It has to make my tech feeds where it might catch my eye.

>zigbee

Dras, be aware that zwave devices can have quite a bit of maintenance baggage over their lifetime. I was $300+ into zwave devices when I first set up hubitat and threw them out in favor of zigbee. Best decision ever.

Rupert

>Aqara
I use their devices with hubitat at times. Same as RC, local and solid.

Cheap old ones on ebay often available to play with. The new ones are just a bit faster, and run more queries at one time, and seem to connect a bit more reliably.  No idea why. I guess it something to do with the way the mesh works.

Zigbee fan here too.
... Make sure you live before you die.