Main Menu

Brexit

Started by rcjordan, June 14, 2016, 11:08:57 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Chunkford

The UK is in the EU with opt-outs.
But the UK wants out of the EU with opt-ins.

Anyone else scratches their head when they try and work that out?
"If my answers frighten you then you should cease asking scary questions"

keano

Brexit is just too wide ranging a subject to have been broached in a simple yes/no referendum (which is technically not legally binding btw). Speak to 10 different people and they will likely give you 10 different reasons why they voted the way they did. It was ridiculous for the referendum to be presented in such a binary and finite way.

Add to the fact that that there seemed to be some dubious claims from the leave camp whilst campaigning which they seemingly won't be held accountable for in any meaningful way and you end up with a subject that nobody fully understands with no clear path forward.

Adam C

Quote from: Chunkford on July 10, 2018, 10:14:51 AM
The UK is in the EU with opt-outs.
But the UK wants out of the EU with opt-ins.

That's the single best argument I've heard to date for Brexit

Rupert

I have quoted that line a couple of times too Chuckford :)
... Make sure you live before you die.

ergophobe

Quote from: Chunkford on July 10, 2018, 10:14:51 AM
The UK is in the EU with opt-outs.
But the UK wants out of the EU with opt-ins.

So basically the UK wants to grow up to be Switzerland?

rcjordan


gm66

The working class people of the UK voted to exit, now the middle classes are paying to reverse the decision, democracy in action!
Civilisation is a race between disaster and education ...

rcjordan

From the flurry of headlines I've seen over the last couple of weeks, it's still shaping up to be a very costly exit with a big dose of PITA over the long term.

rcjordan

From here, it looks like May is getting her ass handed to her.

rcjordan


Rupert

It will go to the wire and the more imho.

Also just So many lies about.

Vince Cable said the other day:
Quotethat half British sheep population would be slaughtered if there was no deal.

Just not true.  Half of lambs are slaughtered every year, because a lamb becomes mutton when it is 2. So technically yes. But not because of a no deal.
Half of lambs grown are eaten in the UK, the rest are exported.  A small number got to the EU.  Most dont. Some to New Zealand(We import lamb back too strangely)

and as for Farrage/ Johnson/gove

I think they should be locked up, the lot of them. 
... Make sure you live before you die.

jetboy

The "no deal" option is May playing chicken with Parliament. i.e. Unless they vote for her deal, that will be the only other option. It's clearly a lie, and hugely irresponsible. It may also be a tactic that works.

Adam C

Dark times ahead.  The country is massively divided.  There needs to be a long term constructive plan in the interest of the majority, but there seems to be little attempt to drive towards this by the extremists.

Chunkford

Majority? it was practically a 50/50 split. The referendum should have had a threshold, to define a clear majority.
"If my answers frighten you then you should cease asking scary questions"

Adam C

It was 50/50 on the blunt in/out question, but that has proven to have been too simple a question to provide a mandate for anyone to successfully action anything.

Time to construct a more meaningful framework for deciding WTF happens next.